South Beach

RESTAURANTS & DINING

Casa Tua Editor's Pick

by / May 14, 2011

Casa Tua Miami Beach

Casa Tua

Neatly tucked away in a secluded residential area on James Avenue, Casa Tua presents a fresh approach to dining in Miami Beach. The ground-level dining area has an eighteen-seat communal chef's table, with a wide-open kitchen area close by, while the second floor contains a five suite boutique hotel. 

Executive chef Sergio Sigala and sous-chef Gabriela Bergomi combine their talents to create innovative variations of Italian cuisine in a glamorously unusual setting that has become the talk of the town in Miami Beach.

 

Restaurant Details

Rating:
4 - 4 stars based on 512 reviews across the Web
Address:
1700 James Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33139
Phone: (305) 673-0973
Cuisine: Italian
Price: $$$$
Attire: Casual Elegant
Payment: Cash, All Major Credit Cards
Reservations: Yes - Reservations recommended but not required
Parking: Street and City Parking Lot two blocks west
Chef:  
Website:
Bar Service: Full Bar
Outdoor Dining: Yes
Delivery: No
Take-Out: No
Caters: No
Wi-Fi: Public
Accessibility: Wheelchair Accessible
Hours: Mo-Fr 11:30am - 11:30pm
Sa 6pm - 1am
Su 6pm - 11:30pm
 
User Reviews

Reviewer:

Carolyn Forest from Miami, FL

Recommended:

No

Overall Rating:

Service:

1-Bad

Ambiance:

1-Bad

Food Quality:

1-Bad

Value for Price:

1-Bad

Review:  This has to be the worst place ever! The waiter ignored my picture to be taken with my family, the bread guy looked the other way when he knew perfectly well I was calling him, when I made my order it was wrong and the waiter said it was too late, the food took too long, the valet people ignore you as well after calling them 3 times, my pasta tasted like lemon mixed with butter, my seat was all wet and they didnt care if it was, and I had to read the menu with a flashlight. This place is so awful I will never step in there again. VERY DISSAPOINTED!!


Reviewer:

David from New York, NY

Recommended:

Yes

Overall Rating:

Service:

4-Good

Ambiance:

5-Excellent

Food Quality:

4-Good

Value for Price:

4-Good

Review:  I live in New York, Have lived in a number of countries in Europe, and have been fortunate enough to have eaten in many of the great eateries in the world. Casa Tua is one of those rare gems that you always go back to. Sitting at an outside table in spring with a knowledgeable waiter and sommelier to make suggestions, enjoying the quiet scene with some good friends ranks as one of the greatest dining experiences in the world.


Reviewer:

Stacy from Ohio

Recommended:

Yes

Overall Rating:

Service:

5-Excellent

Ambiance:

5-Excellent

Food Quality:

5-Excellent

Value for Price:

5-Excellent

Review:  Was above and beyond what we expected! Off the charts excellent! Will go again when we return for another trip!


Reviewer:

Sandra Hanover from Delray Beach, FL

Recommended:

Yes

Overall Rating:

Service:

4-Good

Ambiance:

4-Good

Food Quality:

3-Fair

Value for Price:

1-Bad

Review:  The prices are exorbitant, and the portions are the smallest I have ever had. For instance, the rack of lamb entree consists of 2 tiny lamb chops and minor sides, for a very high price! I am not a big eater, and left hungry, for about $100 per person, not including wine. Yikes! The ambiance is nice, but there are much better choices in South Beach.


Reviewer:

Vanessa from Miami, FL

Recommended:

Yes

Overall Rating:

Service:

5-Excellent

Ambiance:

5-Excellent

Food Quality:

5-Excellent

Value for Price:

5-Excellent

Review:  My experience was great. We went for a special occasion and I must say we all thought it was awesome.


Reviewer:

Christian from Munich, Germany

Recommended:

No

Overall Rating:

Service:

4-Good

Ambiance:

5-Excellent

Food Quality:

3-Fair

Value for Price:

1-Bad

Review:  I had no problems with the staff, but the food there is by European standards just regular Italian food (except for some "minor" misunderstandings regarding the Italian cuisine on the chef's side) making the entire experience totally overpriced.


Reviewer:

Daniel from Miami, FL

Recommended:

Yes

Overall Rating:

Service:

2-Poor

Ambiance:

4-Good

Food Quality:

4-Good

Value for Price:

3-Fair

Review:  It's time for South Beach to get rid of the "I'm too good to be here" waiters. This charming little restaurant with very well prepared plates loses points fast because of poor service. Should the owners choose to change the staff, it could become a great place.


Reviewer:

Jude from Manhattan

Recommended:

Yes

Overall Rating:

Service:

5-Excellent

Ambiance:

5-Excellent

Food Quality:

5-Excellent

Value for Price:

5-Excellent

Review:  Having dined at 5-star restaurants all over the US, I have to say that Casa Tua is right at the top of my list. The food is wonderful and portion size is sort of small, which allows you to try a number of things during the 3-4 courses. This is ideal because you'll want to try everything on the menu after just one bite. The sommelier was extremely helpful and much to our surprise didn't just recommend the most expensive bottle of wine on the menu. The wine selection is excellent offering many new and old world choices as well as prices points for every budget. The service was impeccable, if not a bit too much at times. But definitely better than having to chase down a server for a glass of water. I plan on visiting Casa Tua over and over again.


Reviewer:

Fiorella from Miami, FL

Recommended:

No

Overall Rating:

Service:

1-Bad

Ambiance:

4-Good

Food Quality:

5-Excellent

Value for Price:

4-Good

Review:  The food was amazing but the service was terrible, starting from the hostess to the waiters.


Reviewer:

John E. Hurlstone from Cayman Islands

Recommended:

Yes

Overall Rating:

Service:

5-Excellent

Ambiance:

5-Excellent

Food Quality:

5-Excellent

Value for Price:

4-Good

Review:  Wonderful food and great ambiance


 
Restaurants by Cuisine
ARGENTINE
Baires Grill

CASUAL
Balans
Big Pink
Clarke's
Front Porch Cafe
News Cafe
Nexxt Cafe
Van Dyke

CHINESE
Hakkasan
Philippe Miami

CUBAN
Larios
Puerto Sagua

DELI
Jerry's Famous

FRENCH/BISTRO
A la Folie
La Brioche Doree

HAITIAN
Tap-Tap

GREEK / MED
Pasha's
Sultan Kabob
Taverna Opa

INTERNATIONAL
Michy's
Tantra

ITALIAN
Bianca
Caffe Milano
Casa Tua
da Leo Trattoria
Escopazzo
Grazie
Hosteria Romana
Osteria del Teatro
Pelican Cafe
Piola
Pizza Rustica
Prime Italian
Quattro
Sardinia Enoteca
Scarpetta
Segafredo
Sibilla
Spiga
Spris
Terrazza
TiramesU

JAPANESE
Nobu
Toni's Japanese

MEXICAN
Lolita Cocina
Lucy's Cantina Royale

NEW AMERICAN
11th Street Diner
Bistro One
Barton G
The Dutch
Vida

NUEVO LATINO
De Rodriguez Cuba
Morena
Ola
Sra. Martinez
Yuca

PAN ASIAN
Asia de Cuba
China Grill
Juvia
Lantao Kitchen
The Setai Hotel

SEAFOOD
A Fish Called Avalon
Altamare
Grill Fish
Joe's Stone Crab
La Marea
Pearl
Quinn's

STEAKHOUSE
1500 Degrees
BLT Steak
Edge Steak
Fogo de Chao
The Forge
Gotham Steak
Kane (Closed)
Meat Market
Prime 112
Red
Smith & Wollensky
STK Miami
Texas De Brazil
Vesper

SUSHI
Bar Tanaka
Blade Sushi
Blue Sea
Bond St
Doraku
Shoji Sushi
Sushi Rock Cafe
SushiSamba
Sushi Siam

Contact | About Us